The first thing I wrote for this case wasn't a clue. It was a tag. A little paper tag on red string, hanging off the empty hook at the top of Santa's Great Tree, and it said: "You already have my name. I signed your Naughty List myself."
I laughed at my own desk, which is either a good sign or a bad one. Then I had to build the rest of it, and that took most of November.
How elimination puzzles are made (the Christmas version)
An elimination puzzle is simple to describe. You get a long list of suspects and a short list of clues. Each clue rules some of them out. Work the clues in order, cross off everyone who doesn't fit, and the one name left is your culprit. No guessing, no luck. If you've played The Killer Is in the Ledger, you know the feeling of a pencil going down a column of names.
This one is different in two ways. It's played online, on the Puzzle Desk, so there's no pencil. And it's the first case I've made where every suspect has a first name and a last name.
Building a 25,000-name Naughty List
Twenty-five thousand names is a stack of paper nobody would print. On a phone it's fine: the list is sized to your screen, it has A to Z filters and a search box, and a counter in the corner tells you how many are still standing.
The names are in no particular order. That's on purpose, and it's also the story's best excuse: the List Office gave up on alphabetical order in October. (I relate to the List Office more than I'd like to admit.)
Because every suspect has two names, every door has to say which one it means. Some doors read the first name. Some read the last. A few read the whole thing, first and last together. When you build a door's rule in the Stamp panel, there's a blank that asks you which name you're working on, and it's never filled in for you. That one little blank is where most of the fun (and most of the groaning) lives.
Writing 25 doors that are fair
The clues are behind the doors of an advent calendar the thief left on the hook. None of them describe the crime. Every one describes the thief's name. Here's Door 1, which is the only one I'll show you:
Behind the first door is a sprig of holly with a tag tied to it. The thief's last name comes later in the dictionary than the plant.
The tag says HOLLY. So every suspect whose last name comes alphabetically before HOLLY goes. On the Desk that's 8,711 names in one tap, and the counter rolls from 25,000 down to 16,289. It's the most satisfying thing I've ever made a computer do.
The rule I give myself for every door: it has to be solvable from what's on the page, it has to cut somebody, and it can't be the one that gives the game away too early. Each door is a little picture or note you decode (a carol sheet, a stocking, a string of fairy lights) and then a plain instruction about what to clear. If you get stuck, every door has two Leads on the Desk: one tells you what the picture means, the other shows you how to use it on two real names.
Making sure exactly one name survives
This is the part I can't do by eye. The Puzzle Desk runs every door through the same rule engine you play with, starting from all 25,000 names, and checks that exactly one is left after Door 25, and that it's the right one. If two people survive, the case doesn't get published. If a door clears nobody, it doesn't get published either.
So when I say there's one answer, it's not me being confident. A machine counted.
The extras on the Case Board
Every door has a Thread on the Case Board, which is a corkboard with red string (I'm very proud of it). Pull a door's Thread, pass a quick test from Pepper, the Head of List-Keeping, and the List Office elves lend you that door's stamp. You can always cross names off by hand instead.
There are three Evidence Threads too, about where the star went and why, and five Side Cases that turn up as you go, with names like Double Trouble and Three Mail Sacks. Solve one and you earn a check on your list.
It's for ages 10 and up. Nobody gets hurt. It's a stolen star, and the reason they took it is the part I'm proudest of.
When you can play it
Mystery Vault members on the Simply Creative Puzzles Patreon get it on Saturday, November 21, a week before it goes in the shop on Saturday, November 28. If you'd like to see how the Puzzle Desk feels before then, there's a free five-minute demo case with no sign-up. And if you're more of a paper person, No Vacancy at the Grand Meridian has 25,000 hotel guests and a pencil's worth of fun.
The thief said one door a day should do it. You don't have to listen to the thief.
0 Comments
Be the first to comment.